How Much Should I Size Cases
Q: I'm puzzled about how much a rifle case should be sized when reloading? I've always adjusted the die down to touch the shellholder, and the cartridges feed smoothly though my rifle. But the guy in my local gunshop says this can cause problems. He says a "crush" fit is more nearly ideal, because there is no slop in the chamber and reloads will shoot better and the cases last longer. He advised against screwing the sizing die down until it contacts the shellholder unless it is necessary to get the round the chamber. I don't have any problems with case life as it is, but which is the right way to go about resizing?
A: You both make a point, but more importantly you should understand the reasoning behind one method or the other. Most times, screwing the sizing die down to touch the shellholder brings the round back pretty close to factory dimensions. As a rule they will generally feed and chamber easily. However, if you strike problems with case head separations or cracks just forward of the case web, you're setting the shoulder back too far with each sizing. This means you should back off a little.
While it's true that a "crush" fit will eliminate excessive headspace and prolong case life, it can be a problem if it's overdone. Occasionally, a case won't quite be a "crush" fit and may not chamber at all. I suggest you adjust the sizing die to touch the shellholder and then back it off just enough so that your reloads chamber with a slight "feel" as the bolt handle turns down. When reloading for hunting I prefer to use new or near-new brass and full length resize so that the rounds chamber smoothly. I don't want to risk blowing a chance at a real trophy animal because a reload was too tight or got stuck in the chamber.